Doctoral theses written by INSS members
Scholars who have recently completed, or who are nearing the completion of, a doctoral thesis in the field of spirituality studies are invited to join INSS and to display an Abstract of their thesis on these networking pages.
Contact Melanie Rogers (M.Rogers@hud.ac.uk) for further information.
Name: Gulnar Ali
Main field of study: Nursing Education - Advanced Practice
Title: MULTIPLE CASE STUDIES EXPLORING INTEGRATION OF SPIRITUALITY IN UNDERGRADUATE NURSING EDUCATION IN ENGLAND
PhD, completed 2017. University of Huddersfield, UK, Department of Human and Health Sciences
Introduction: Difficulties persist in conceptualising spiritual needs and understanding their relationship to religious needs and wellbeing in healthcare and particularly in nursing education. This research was undertaken to explore approaches and challenges associated with this area in undergraduate nursing education in England.
Methods/Methodology: Using a systematic approach, a literature review covering the period 1993-2017 was undertaken to explore potential issues and challenges reported. Applying case-study methodology, data were collected from three university nursing schools from different parts of England. Sources for data triangulation within schools included, curriculum review of undergraduate nursing courses, exploring the views of nursing educators through semi structured interviews and focus group studies with nursing students. Template analysis was used to identify themes in the data.
Findings: Due to the module-based curriculum, the integration of spirituality in nursing education appeared to be treated as a matter of personal choice and convenience rather than as an essential domain of teaching and learning practice in England. Owing to conceptual complexity, addressing religious needs was often considered to be synonymous with addressing spiritual care need. Factors were identified contributing to the difficulties in the issue of educating nurses in this area. These were: lack of clarity in curriculum documents; uncertainty as to how far nurses should address these issues and how far this was a specialist chaplaincy function; fear of being judged or rejected in a multicultural environment; and the dominance of disease-centred care. The participants voiced a desire for developing a shared understanding through developing a more explicit representation of spirituality in nursing education and the recognition of appropriate educational approaches in this area. Based on the findings of this study a learning framework is proposed; SOPHIE (Self-exploration through Ontological, Phenomenological, Humanistic, Ideological, and Existential expressions), to encourage self-awareness and reflexivity among nursing educators and students. SOPHIE aims to bring ontological authenticity and congruency to the forefront of nursing knowledge and practice.
Conclusion: Constructing knowledge through ontological learning engagements among educators and students is essential to develop role clarity, authenticity and empowerment in understanding and addressing spiritual care needs. A multidisciplinary teaching approach integrating medical anthropology, humanistic psychology and existential phenomenology should be explored as a basis for an integrated nursing curriculum that could explore spirituality in its widest sense.
Name: Guy Harrison
Main field of study: Psychotherapy, Health and Spiritual Care
Title: THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN COUNSELLING AND PSYCHOTHERAPY AND SPIRITUAL AND PASTORAL CARE IN THE PRACTICE OF A HEALTHCARE CHAPLAIN: AN AUTOETHNOGRAPHIC NARRATIVE CASE STUDY EVALUATION
D.Psych, completed 2016. Middlesex University, UK, School of Science & Technology, Metanoia Doctoral Studies Department
This project describes and evaluates the relationship between counselling and psychotherapy and spiritual and pastoral care in my practice as Head of Spiritual and Pastoral Care within an NHS Trust. The literature suggests that a gap in knowledge exists regarding the relationship between therapeutic practice and spiritual and pastoral care. The purpose of the research is to generate insight into this relationship within a multi-disciplinary context in order to clarify the role and contribute to both the knowledge base and the development of practice. The project comprises a personal story researched through an in-depth, single narrative case study of practice, set within an autoethnographic frame. Field stories of my practice are presented using the lens of a researcher-practitioner interpretation of what took place. A reflexive approach is adopted in order to convey as faithful an account as possible of the elements of each encounter.
The reflective nature of the writing is both iterative and creative in its approach. The findings demonstrate that within the complexities of the role of the chaplain who is also a therapist it is possible to bring together psychological, spiritual and pastoral insights into practice in ways that are integrative and holistic. The research evidence together with the products associated with it also demonstrates the current lack of conceptual clarity around the role and the need to describe its psychotherapeutic, spiritual and pastoral integrity and identity.
The study describes an integrated psycho-spiritual approach and concludes that its adoption makes it possible to integrate training and experience in both counselling and psychotherapy and spiritual and pastoral care. It offers the proposition that integration of contemporary spirituality with practical theological insights and the application of a Person Centred therapy can act as a resource for the development of what is described as Radical Presence.
Contact: Dept of Spiritual & Pastoral Care, Oxford Health NHS Foundation Trust, CS Building, Littlemore Mental Health Unit, Sandford Rd, Littlemore, Oxford OX4 4XN.
Name: Nasreen Lalani
Main field of study: Nursing
Title: RISE ABOVE: EXPERIENCES OF SPIRITUALITY AMONG FAMILY CAREGIVERS OF PALLIATIVE CARE PATIENTS IN A HOSPICE SETTING IN PAKISTAN
PhD, completed 2018. University of Alberta, Canada, Department of Nursing and Midwifery
Background: Family caregivers play a vital role during the time of illness of a family member. Family caregivers experience various physical, emotional, psychosocial, and spiritual concerns while caring for a family member with a life-threatening illness, especially in a hospice setting. Current literature mainly adds to understanding the physical, psychological, and emotional aspects of family caregiving. Spiritual aspects of family caregiving such as personal values and the meanings that family caregivers ascribe to their caregiving roles often remain unaddressed. While caring for a seriously ill family member receiving palliative care, family caregivers go through multiple transitions, make new resolutions, adjust to changing roles and expectations, and experience grief and other complex caregiving situations where their search for meaning becomes evident. There is an increasing need to explore such experiences of spirituality among family caregivers to support their caregiving actions and practices.
Purpose: The study aimed to describe the experiences of spirituality among family caregivers and how these experiences shape their family caregiving practices while caring for a terminally ill family member in a hospice setting in Karachi, Pakistan.
Research Design: Interpretive descriptive design guided the study. Individual in-depth interviews were used as a method of data collection. Study setting was Baitul-Sukoon Cancer Hospital and Hospice in Karachi, Pakistan. A sample of family caregivers (n=18) and healthcare professionals (n=5) was selected from a cancer hospice facility in Karachi. A total of 28 interviews were taken from the family caregiver participants. For collateral data collection, 5 interviews were taken from the healthcare providers. The qualitative data analysis software, Quirkos, was used to manage the data. Permission for the study was obtained from the Bait-ul-Sukoon Hospice. Ethical approval was obtained from Human Research Ethics Board of the University of Alberta.
Results/Findings: Demographic characteristics of family caregivers showed that mean age of family caregivers was 34.06years. 83% were Muslims, 78% were female, 72% were married, 28% did not have any formal education, and 72% were living in extended families. 61% reported their income between Canadian $160-200/month. The average caregiving period was 1.72years. Analysis of the rich descriptions revealed four themes under study which were: family love, attachment, and belongingness; honoring family values and dignity; acts of compassion and selfless service; and seeking God’s kindness and grace. All these themes led to a central theme ‘rise above or self-transcendence’. The four themes reflect the unique experiences of spirituality among family caregivers. Family caregivers identified their uncertainties, losses, and sufferings as part of life and perceived them as invitations to open themselves to the depths of their spirits and to the support, service, and love of others as they experienced ‘rise above’ or self-transcendence. Family caregivers uncovered meaningful engagement, a sense of belonging, and a sense of attachment while serving family and others. They highly valued the love, respect, and honor of the family, showed compassion, believed in God’s blessings and grace and experienced constant spiritual growth and self-transcendence.
Conclusion: My findings present a novel perspective of spirituality and family caregiving from an Eastern context. Findings signify that spirituality is a major resource of coping among family caregivers. Healthcare professionals need to acknowledge and develop spiritual care interventions to support family caregivers’ spirituality and spiritual wellbeing at the end of life in the hospice setting.
Name: Sophie MacKenzie
Main field of study: Speech and Language Therapy
Title: MOSAICS, AMBIGUITY AND QUEST: cONSTRUCTING STORIES OF SPIRITUALITY WITH PEOPLE WITH EXPRESSIVE APHASIA
PhD, completed 2017. Canterbury Christ Church University, UK, Department of Health and Wellbeing
Despite the current emphasis on person centred, holistic care in health, the concept of spirituality has been discussed very little in the field of speech and language therapy (SLT). The nursing spirituality literature has proliferated in the last twenty years but, by contrast, very few SLT studies exist which mention the spiritual needs of patients with communication problems and how they express them. Individuals experiencing severe, life-changing events, such as a stroke, may need to engage with and discuss their spiritual needs, in order to make sense of what has happened to them. The aim of this study was to discover what it is like to express spiritual issues when one has an acquired communication impairment (aphasia). I also wanted to discover what it is like to be a
healthcare professional working with people with communication impairment expressing their spirituality. I used a phenomenological approach in order to interview eight people with aphasia about their spirituality. Participants with aphasia used a variety of strategies to express these ideas, which included employing non-verbal communication techniques, such as gesture, writing key words, intonation and artefacts. I also interviewed five members of the multidisciplinary stroke team (MDT) about what it is like to work holistically with people with aphasia. Each interview resulted in a participant story. People with aphasia talked about religious themes, such as visions and prayer, but also non-religious life meaning-makers, such as gardening and art. MDT members discussed themes such as spirituality as part of their remit and giving the patient time to communicate. The stories were then explored through the interpretive lens of some concepts propounded by Merleau-Ponty (2002), namely ambiguity, lived body, language and thought, and wonder. Frank’s illness narratives (chaos, restitution and quest) were also considered in order to analyse the participants’ stroke journey in relation to expressing spirituality. People with aphasia can and do discuss their spiritual concerns, particularly when they are entering a quest phase of their illness narrative. They employ many non-verbal mosaics in order to convey spiritual issues, and are helped by the listener employing a phenomenological attitude of openness and attentiveness. Healthcare professionals expressed their willingness to listen to their patients’ spiritual stories, in the interests of holistic practice. Being able to express spiritual needs can enhance wellbeing, help foster therapeutic rapport, and enable people to engage more fully in the rehabilitation process.
Name: Ronita Mahilall
Main field of study: Spiritual Care in Palliative Care
Title: SPIRITUAL CARE IN HOSPICE PALLIATIVE CARE SETTINGS IN SOUTH AFRICA: NATIONAL CURRICULUM NEEDS, DESCRIPTION OF PROVINCIAL SERVICES, AND A LOCAL CASE STUDY
PhD, completed 2021. Stellenbosch University, South Africa, Department of Psychology
Palliative care is gaining momentum in South Africa. Spiritual care is slowly being recognised as an important component of palliative care and hospice work. However, how spiritual care services are offered and prioritised depends largely on the hospices’ ability to fund this service and to have the necessary skilled spiritual care staff in place to offer this specialised service. The aim of this study was to explore if hospices in palliative care settings in South Africa offered spiritual care services, how spiritual care services were offered, what the spiritual care training needs are and, more critically, to explore if there was a need to develop a national spiritual care training curriculum.
To answer these questions, I conducted a three-tiered study. In Sub-Study One, I conducted an online survey of all hospices registered as member organizations of Hospice Palliative Care Association of South Africa. The aim of this Sub-Study One was to explore what spiritual care services were currently being offered at hospices nationally, what spiritual care training needs existed and, how hospices suggested filling the training gap. In Sub-Study Two, I conducted focused group discussions with hospices in the Western Cape province of South Africa. These focus groups explored the above questions but with a focused view on issues of multi-layered contextual diversities and inequalities which, largely, are by-products of the South African apartheid era. Sub-Study Three took the form of one-on-one interviews and focused group discussions with participants who are practising spiritual care workers registered with St Luke’s Combined Hospices in Cape Town, to explore how they offer spiritual care services and navigate issues of diversity. Further, I explored this cohort’s spiritual care training needs and their ideas of developing a national spiritual care curriculum for South Africa.
The findings of this three-part study suggest that hospices in South Africa offer spiritual care services to varying levels, and where such a service is not on offer, arrangements are made to link patients and families to external resources. Common to the three sub-studies was the expressed need to develop a national spiritual care training curriculum that had both an academic and practical component to it. However, the realities of limited funding and limited expertise in spiritual care was a significant consideration towards developing a spiritual care curriculum. Added to that was the consideration of the multi-layered diversities that are part of South Africa and its troubled history. These findings present further perspectives on the fluid, dynamic and often multifaceted nature of an aspect of health care provision in South Africa. The study concluded by outlining some potential next steps for developing further dialogues on spiritual care services in South Africa.
Name: Katja Milner
Main field of study: Health sciences, Health care, Mental health and Spirituality
Title: THE ROLE OF SPIRITUALITY IN MENTAL HEALTH AND RECOVERY
PhD (ESRC Mental health and wellbeing pathway), expected) date of completion: early 2022. University of Nottingham, UK, School of Health Sciences, Department of Medicine and Health Sciences, Institute of Mental Health
Introduction: Despite an increasing awareness of the importance of spirituality in mental health contexts, it is often still a neglected dimension within practice. Some researchers have identified a ‘religiosity gap’ highlighting a lack of understanding and addressing of service users’ spiritual needs by mental healthcare providers. In addition, much existing research on spirituality and health focuses on clinical outcomes rather than exploring the relationship between spirituality and mental health and recovery from the perspectives of those who experience mental health issues. This research project aims to address this gap in knowledge and the research question: What is the role of spirituality in mental health and recovery. It does this in two stages. First, exploring the experiences of spirituality among adults with mental health difficulties through a qualitative systematic review. Second, using a narrative methodology to explore the role of spirituality in 30 stories of people who have current or previous experiences of mental health difficulties, focussing specifically on the way people use spirituality to find meaning in their experiences and how this process develops over time.
Methods/Methodology: A qualitative research design has been chosen as it can illuminate understanding of lived experiences and bring comprehensive insight into complex areas such as spirituality. Study 1: Qualitative Systematic review. An electronic search of seven databases was conducted along with searching bibliographies and forward-referencing of all eligible studies, hand-searching journal contents pages and expert consultation. Thirty-eight published studies were identified which met the inclusion criteria. Study 2: Narrative Interview Study A narrative methodology was chosen. After obtaining ethical approval, a purposive sampling method was used to recruit 30 adult participants within non-NHS settings. Participants were interviewed for on average an hour to an hour and a half using narrative interviews.
Findings: Study 1: A thematic synthesis of the study findings identified six key themes: Meaning-making, Identity, Service-provision, Talk about it, Interaction with symptoms and Coping, which can be presented as the acronym MISTIC (Milner et al., 2020) Study 2: Being carried out.
Conclusion: Still in progress. Clinical implications include the production of a conceptual framework that healthcare providers can utilise to aid understanding and address people’s spiritual needs within healthcare practice. The outcomes of this research aim to contribute to the production of evidence, theory and training resources used by clinicians and mental health services. These could enable better understanding of service users’ spiritual experiences and needs, highlighting a paradigm of healthcare delivery which integrates the spiritual dimension into an evolving recovery approach.
Name: Melanie Rogers
Main field of study: Health - Advanced PracticeTitle: SPIRITUAL DIMENSIONS OF ADVANCED NURSE PRACTITIONER CONSULTATIONS IN PRIMARY CARE THROUGH THE LENS OF AVAILABILITY AND VULNERABILITY: A HERMENEUTIC ENQUIRY
PhD, completed 2016. University of Huddersfield, UK, Department of Nursing and Midwifery
Introduction: There is a scarcity of research examining spirituality and spiritual dimensions of Advanced Nurse Practitioner practice. This thesis explores the findings of a hermeneutic enquiry into the spiritual dimensions of Advanced Nurse Practitioner consultations in Primary Care through the lens of Availability and Vulnerability. The findings include Advanced Nurse Practitioners’ understandings and conceptualisation of spirituality, the place of spirituality in practice and some of the concerns related to integration in practice. The participants’ interviews explored their own personal and professional experiences which added to their conceptualisation of spirituality. The lens of Availability and Vulnerability (A&V) was used intentionally and openly to explore, in depth, spiritual dimension of practice with the participants. The utility and effectiveness of the concepts of A&V in this context was explored.
Methods/Methodology: A hermeneutic phenomenological enquiry was chosen to explore spirituality through the lived experiences of the Advanced Nurse Practitioners (ANPs). Eight participants were interviewed face to face during 2 in-depth interviews spaced 18 months apart. The concepts of A&V were introduced to the participants before the second interviews. The lens of A&V was utilised within these interviews to discover whether or not these concepts were helpful for operationalising spirituality in practice. The prolonged engagement allowed dialogue to occur between the researcher and participants allowing data to be captured which provided a thick description of the phenomenon of spirituality. A thematic analysis was chosen to interpret the data in order to enable a deeper understanding of the spiritual dimensions of ANP consultations to be gained.
Findings: The participants recognised that spirituality can be difficult to conceptualise and operationalise in practice. However, many of the participants were able to articulate the meaning of spirituality for themselves and gave examples of when they had witnessed a spiritual dimension occurring in practice. Particular themes were expressed in the interviews in relationship to spirituality. These included the context for spirituality to be integrated into care, the emotional engagement needed and the emotional impact on the ANP and the patient. Having introduced the concepts of A&V to the participants, after deep exploration, they recognised and identified that A&V were concepts which could be a useful lens for understanding spirituality in ANP consultations.
Conclusion: This study has uncovered new knowledge and understanding in the realm of spirituality in ANP consultations in Primary Care. The conceptual understanding of spirituality and the framework of Availability and Vulnerability provides a new approach to spirituality within ANP consultations in Primary Care.
Name: Catherine Lambert
Main field of study: Spirituality, Spiritual DirectionTitle: Dwelling on the Edge: A Spiritual Director Hears Contemporary Women Respond to the Beguine Mystics
PhD, March 2022, University of Divinity, Melbourne
‘Reading [the beguines] increased my thirst to be able to live faithfully on the fringe’. (Alice)
Like Alice and other participants in this study, many contemporary women who seek spiritual direction find themselves dwelling on the edge of formal church communities. Training programs for spiritual direction have not focused on the experience of those disenchanted with the church. Many do draw on the inherited experience of earlier seekers but with exemplars recognised within the institution, especially from monastic and Ignatian traditions. For contemporary women disenchanted with the institutional church, models deeply rooted within the tradition may not be the most helpful. In order to explore the value of exemplars from the edge of the tradition for the practice of spiritual direction, this interdisciplinary study introduced a group of contemporary Australian women to the lives and writings of thirteenth-century beguine mystics and sought their responses to the experience. This study asks the questions: How do contemporary women on the edge of the church respond to the lives and works of the beguine mystics from the thirteenth century? And what are the implications for the practice of spiritual direction?
Using Constructivist Grounded Theory, the project involved three depth hearings. First, listening to the stories from a sample group of thirteen contemporary women of their journeys to the edge of the church. Then, and concurrently, reading the texts of three beguines; Hadewijch of Brabant, Mechthild of Magdeburg and Marguerite Porete. These two depth hearings supported the development of a contemplative resource for the sample group. The third depth hearing collated their responses to their engagement with the beguines.
Findings and Conclusions:
Overall, the struggle to discover their own inner spiritual authority connected the women across centuries. In identifying this resonance, the contemporary women developed a relationship with the beguines that transformed and influenced their own journeys. Their encounters underline the importance of remembering the beguine mystics, the value of this method of contemplative engagement with historical mystics and the need for explicit validation of the richness of the edges of tradition within spiritual direction.